Pterodactyl vs Pelican vs PufferPanel — Best Self-Hosted Game Server Panel Compared

Pterodactyl vs Pelican vs PufferPanel - self-hosted game server panels compared

Ask a self-hosting forum how to run a Minecraft, Palworld or Valheim server for friends and you will get one answer: Pterodactyl. It earned that reputation. A clean web panel, a daemon that puts every game server in its own Docker container, and a huge library of community-made “eggs” that describe how to install and run almost any game. But it is no longer the only serious choice. Pelican Panel is a fork from people who worked on Pterodactyl and wanted a faster-moving successor, and PufferPanel goes the other way: fewer moving parts, less hardware, less to learn. Here is how the three differ when you are the person doing the install.

All three are free software with a web interface for creating servers, watching consoles and managing files. What separates them is what sits underneath.

1. Pterodactyl — The Incumbent

Pterodactyl is a PHP and React panel paired with Wings, a Go daemon that runs on each node and starts every game server inside an isolated Docker container. The panel never runs game code itself; it talks to Wings, and Wings does the container work. That split is why a single panel can drive several machines, and why a broken game server cannot take the panel down with it.

2. Pelican — The Fork That Moved On

Pelican is a fork of the Pterodactyl panel maintained by former contributors to that project. The architecture will feel familiar: a Laravel panel manages one or more nodes, and each server runs in an isolated Docker container through Wings, which Pelican maintains as its own fork. Eggs come from the Pelican eggs organisation, covering Minecraft, SteamCMD titles, bots, databases and voice servers.

3. PufferPanel — The Lightweight Option

PufferPanel aims at personal servers and small networks rather than hosting companies. It ships as a single Go binary that serves the web panel and manages the servers on the node, so there is no separate daemon to pair with it. Servers run in an environment you choose, either directly on the host or inside Docker, and each user gets their own servers and permissions.

Head-to-Head

Which One Should You Pick?

The Bottom Line

Pterodactyl is still the right answer for most people, because the egg catalogue solves the problem you will hit: getting a specific game installed correctly. Pelican is the one to watch, and the one to choose if you want to be on the branch where development is happening. PufferPanel is underrated for the small case, where the Pterodactyl stack is more machinery than a single server needs.

Browse more self-hosted tooling in the full directory, or suggest a tool we have missed.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Sign In

Register

Reset Password

Please enter your username or email address, you will receive a link to create a new password via email.